What Does It Really Take for a Brand to Grow?
6 mins read

What Does It Really Take for a Brand to Grow?

TRENDSETTERS | Madita Brandhorst, Associate Director of Tracking Solutions, quantilope

Marketers have spent years measuring brand awareness, tracking performance, and calculating returns. But what if the more important question is not whether consumers know a brand, but what makes them think of it when they’re ready to buy?

For more than 15 years, the concept of Mental Availability has helped reshape how marketers understand brand growth. Yet one fundamental question has remained surprisingly difficult to answer: What does good actually look like?

Madita Brandhorst, Associate Director of Tracking Solutions at quantilope, believes new benchmarks are helping marketers find an answer. Drawing on research spanning thousands of brands and nearly 8,000 data points, she is examining how Mental Availability differs across markets, industries, and stages of brand development — and what those differences reveal about opportunities for growth.

Her findings suggest that the familiar rules of brand building may be more universal than marketers assume, even as the opportunities to grow vary considerably.


Watch the full TRENDSETTERS conversation with Madita Brandhorst on Internationalist Marketing TV.

View a quick clip

Listen to the podcast


Knowing a Brand Isn’t the Same as Thinking of It

Brand awareness has long been a familiar measure of marketing success. But Madita Brandhorst argues that knowing a brand exists is only part of the story.

The more revealing question is what consumers associate with that brand — and which needs, occasions, or buying situations bring it to mind. These associations, known as Category Entry Points, help explain why consumers consider particular brands at particular moments.

For marketers, the distinction is significant. A brand can be widely recognized without being strongly associated with the situations that drive purchasing decisions. And understanding those associations becomes especially valuable when comparing performance against competitors.

Why Brand Growth Looks Different Around the World

One of the research’s most striking findings concerns geography.

In established markets such as North America and Europe, Mental Market Share above approximately 12% places a brand among the top 20% of performers. Yet in parts of Asia-Pacific and Latin America, some brands achieve scores of 30% to 50%.

Brandhorst attributes much of this difference to category maturity, competitive intensity, and first-mover advantages.

As categories become more crowded, brands compete for a finite amount of consumer attention. Their Mental Availability scores tend to move closer together. In less developed categories, however, an early entrant may establish particularly strong associations before competitors arrive.

The implications extend beyond benchmarking. They raise important questions about how multinational marketers evaluate brand strength, introduce innovations, and identify growth opportunities across markets.

A performance considered exceptional in one market may represent a very different competitive position in another.

There Is No Growth Ceiling. But the Playbook Changes.

What happens when a brand is already among the most mentally available in its category?

Madita Brandhorst challenges the idea of an absolute growth ceiling. Growth, she argues, remains possible — but the strategy must reflect the brand’s position and the maturity of its category.

Smaller brands may find opportunities by identifying consumer needs or buying situations that established competitors have overlooked. Larger brands operating in mature or contracting categories face a different challenge. They may need to innovate, introduce new benefits, or address barriers that prevent consumers from participating in the category.

The essential lesson is that growth strategies cannot be separated from competitive context.

Knowing where a brand stands matters. Understanding what that position makes possible matters more.

The Surprising Similarity Between Ice Cream, Insurance, and Automobiles

Perhaps the finding that most surprised her was how consistently Mental Availability principles appeared to work across industries.

She had expected substantial differences between frequently purchased consumer goods and categories involving longer purchase cycles, contracts, or more complex decisions.

Instead, the research revealed more similarities than she anticipated. Whether someone is buying shampoo, insurance, or a car, the underlying decision still involves a person responding to particular needs and circumstances.

There are differences, certainly. But her findings suggest that marketers may sometimes overestimate how exceptional their own industries really are. That observation also raises a larger question: Are the fundamentals of human decision-making more consistent than the marketing strategies built around them?

What Happens When AI Helps Consumers Choose?

The conversation takes an intriguing turn when Madita Brandhorst considers AI-driven brand recommendations.

If consumers increasingly ask AI systems which products or services meet their needs, what happens to the traditional concept of Mental Availability? She sees an important connection between Category Entry Points and the contextual information AI systems use to generate recommendations.

She points to research comparing how brands appear in AI-generated recommendations, suggesting that broad recognition alone may not determine which brands are suggested for a specific need. It is an emerging hypothesis rather than an established equivalence between human memory and AI systems. Nevertheless, the implication is worth exploring.

Brands may increasingly need to be associated with relevant needs and occasions not only in consumers’ minds, but also in the information environments that influence their choices.

And that makes a deep understanding of consumers potentially more valuable, not less.

Bringing Brand Back Into the Conversation

She concludes with a concern that reaches well beyond Mental Availability. Marketing has become exceptionally good at generating measurements. Return on investment, acquisition costs, and digital performance indicators have made enormous amounts of information available.

But she wonders whether the industry has spent too long emphasizing immediate returns while underinvesting in the strength of brands themselves.

The next challenge may be determining which measures genuinely help businesses grow — and using them to make better decisions. For Madita Brandhorst, Mental Availability provides one way to reconnect marketing measurement with the human needs and buying situations that ultimately shape demand.

Perhaps the most important question is no longer simply how much marketers can measure, but whether they understand what will make their brands matter when consumers are ready to choose.